Castle Rock resident and Sheplers part owner dies at 74
Joseph Pagnotta, who helped build the retail business and played football at the University of Colorado, passed away on October 26.
By Lucas Navarro ·
Joseph Michael Pagnotta died on Sunday, October 26, 2026, in Castle Rock, Colorado. He was 74 years old. Family members reported that he was surrounded by his wife, children, and closest relatives when he died.
Pagnotta was born on March 19, 1952, in Pueblo, Colorado. He built a career in retail, rising to become a part owner of the company Sheplers. Colleagues and family described him as a leader who took pride in teaching others and helping them succeed.
He attended the University of Colorado as a student-athlete, competing in both football and track. The obituary notes he remained a lifelong fan of college and professional sports, specifically cheering on the Colorado Buffaloes, the Denver Broncos, and the Denver Nuggets.
Pagnotta is survived by his wife, Shari. He leaves behind three children: Joeilyn Pagnotta, Ryan Pagnotta, and Matthew Pagnotta. He also had two grandchildren, Siena and Giovanni.
His parents, Pete and Rose Pagnotta, and his brother, Anthony Pagnotta, died before him.
A memorial mass is scheduled for Wednesday, November 11, 2026, at 10 a.m. The service will take place at St. Francis of Assisi Catholic Church in Castle Rock.
More News · Castle Rock news · Report a business · Got a Story?
